The Silent Patient

‘The Silent Patient’ by Alex Michaelides, a novel attracts readers of psychological thrillers, particularly those interested in the themes of trauma, silence, and the human psyche from beginning to end.

The whole plot revolves around Alicia Berenson, a tormented painter who one day killed her husband, Gabriel, and resultantly stops speaking for the rest of the novel. Alicia becomes a paradoxical figure; her silence alienates her, leading to her confinement in a mental health facility called The Grove. ‘The Silent Patient’ is first person narrative. Theo Faber, the narrater having a criminal profiler in forensic psychology who becomes obsessed with solving Alicia’s case and unfolding the mystery behind her silence and the reality of what transpired on the night of the killing. Theo’s investigation into Alicia’s life, her lovers, her paintings, and her mental conditions become the root of the plot. The chapters alternate between Theo’s perspective and Alicia’s diary entries, which give a glimpse into her life before the tragedy. Although troubled, these entries only hint at the impending unrest.

As Theo further involves into Alicia’s background, he unleashes multiple lies, infidelity, and hidden abuse in her past, ultimately leading to an unpresidented mould in the story. This twist can be evident as a brilliant move by Michaelides, revealing everything the reader has come to understand on its head, coercing them to rethink their perceptions of the characters and episodes.

The theme of “talking without words” is a dominant and priceless element in the ‘The Silent Patient’: silence as a language and as a form of protection. Silence here is not merely the absence of speech but a deliberate and meaningful decision. Alicia’s choice to remain silent is her protest against the narratives others try to impose on her. Her silence transforms her into an object reflecting those who observe her from the outside, such as Theo, while simultaneously enshrouding her in a character unknown to herself and others. It is crucial to note that the novel’s structure is psychologically intricate, especially in the way Alicia and Theo are portrayed as variations of each other.

The novel also explores the function of art as a manifestation of the internal battles within the characters, as well as a means of concealing them. The symbols in Alicia’s paintings, particularly her final piece, ‘Alcestis’—inspired by the myth of a woman who sacrifices herself for her husband—are laden with significance and offer clues to her psychological state.

Trauma is a prominent feature of both characters, making them focal points of the story. Theo’s own troubled past and failed marriage add depth to his character, evoking sympathy despite his role as the narrator. Theo’s desire to understand Alicia’s feelings and relationships is not only professional but also rooted in his need to comprehend his own loneliness and suffering, which mirrors Alicia’s.

The novel also explores the function of art as a manifestation of the internal battles within the characters, as well as a means of concealing them. The symbols in Alicia’s paintings, particularly her final piece, ‘Alcestis’—inspired by the myth of a woman who sacrifices herself for her husband—are laden with significance and offer clues to her psychological state. Michaelides’ depiction of human emotions, both in the art and in the narrative, immerses the reader in a world of raw human experience.

‘The Silent Patient’ is written in a concise style, which also influences the novel’s structure: the chapters are short and pithy, and Michaelides maintains a fast pace throughout the book. The plot flows steadily and deliberately, building to an unexpected climax.

The alternation between Theo’s investigation and Alicia’s diary entries adds an extra layer to the narrative, allowing the reader to piece together the puzzle alongside the protagonist. Michaelides’ ability to evoke feelings of confinement and discomfort is one of the novel’s strongest aspects, as the reader feels drawn into the depths of the human psyche. However, some critiques of the novel should be mentioned. While the plot’s reliance on a single twist is executed well, it might be perceived as a manipulative device. Additionally, the secondary characters at times seem unrealistic, as if they exist solely to fulfill specific roles rather than having their own independent existence. However, these flaws do not significantly detract from the novel’s overall impact.

‘The Silent Patient’ is a thrilling exploration of the human mind, trauma, and the barriers people build in their lives. The story moves in the reader’s consciousness, offering a rich, thought-provoking experience. Alex Michaelides not only illustrates the murder mystery and the complexities of the main characters but also navigates the subjectivity of trauma, making this debut a standout in the field of psychological thrillers.

Dr. Fatima Aslam

The author is a pharmacist with keen interests in politics and society.

• Dr. Fatima Aslam

  https://spinetimes.pk/author/dr-fatima-aslam/

  Honor Killings in Pakistan: A Deep-Rooted Instrument of Gender Based Violence and Social Control
• Dr. Fatima Aslam

  https://spinetimes.pk/author/dr-fatima-aslam/

  Pakistan's Population Explosion Amid Economic Crisis: An Irony